AIJ Review Form

===============

 

Part A

------

Please answer the following questions "yes/no" and provide appropriate justification as appropriate.

 

CONTENT

Is the paper technically sound?

 

Does it show sufficient applicability to AI?

 

Does it place new results in appropriate context with earlier work?

 

Is the paper sufficiently novel? (A paper is novel if the results it describes 

were not previously published by other authors, and were not previously published 

by the same authors in any archival journal.)

 

Is the paper complete? (Generally, a paper is complete if it includes all relevant proofs 

and/or experimental data, a thorough  discussion of connections with the existing literature, 

and a convincing discussion of the motivations and implications of the presented work.)

 

Does anything need to be added or deleted?

 

Is the result important enough to warrant publication?

 

FORM

Does the abstract adequately reflect the contents?

 

Are the summary and conclusions adequate?

 

Does it contain adequate references to previous work?

 

Does it explain clearly what was done that is new?

 

Does it clearly indicate why this work is important?

 

Is the English satisfactory?

 

Is the presentation otherwise satisfactory?

 

Are there an appropriate number of figures?

 

Do the figures help clarify the concepts in the paper?

 

 

Part B: DETAILED COMMENTS

-------------------------

Please provide a detailed review of the paper here.